Thursday, January 15, 2009

Gender Stereotypes in Corporate India, A Glimpse, Book review by Johnson Thomas

Book Title: Gender Stereotypes in Corporate India
Sub-title: A Glimpse
Author: Sujoya Basu
Response, Business Books from Sage
ISBN 978-81-7829-851-1
Pages :219 Price: Rs.270/- Paperback Edition
www.sagepublications.com

Author Sujoya Basu’s infinite curiosity as to why a large number of Indian women did not make it to the managerial cadre led her to a research and investigation that encompasses this book titled ‘Gender stereotypes in corporate India’. Firstly, She reviewed literature on western management which seemed to suggest that most negative outcomes for women managers in organizations right from inception to progression could largely be a consequence of the inaccurate perceptions regarding women managers. This led her to a comparative study of the Indian management scenario, looking into the exixting perceptions regarding women managers in India, what led to those perceptions and whether those perceptions or stereotypes could be altered to bring about a positive change in organizations. Three studies addressing each of these issues- the first giving a set of managerial gender stereotypes held by men and women in India, the second looked at the antecedents of inaccurate managerial gender stereotypes while the third helped verify whether having women managers in organizational task situations help change inaccurate stereotypes in organizations. The effort is laudatory. This has never been attempted in India before and Sujoya Basu, a member of the faculty of Behavioural sciences at the Indian Institute of Management, Kolkata, India, should get due credit for her singular effort in clearing out the cobwebs regarding gender stereotypes in Indian corporations. Sujoya hopes to make this book a bridge that could fill in the gap that exists in the Indian gender management scenario. Her findings are important in that there is now a record on inaccurate perceptions and stereotypes that divided genders in Indian Industry. This book will help corporates manage their human resources in a much more dignified and humane manner, giving equal respect and providing equal opportunities to both genders. This book also has implications for educators, trainers and society in general. There is no doubt that gender stereotypes have affected the very fabric of the society we depend on for the past decades. It is time now to confront those very perceptions with facts, introducing a greater deal of understanding regarding a very intricate issue of capabilities viz-a-viz gender.

Johnson Thomas

Saturday, January 3, 2009

News Values, Authors: Paul Brighton & Dennis Foy, Book Review by Johnson Thomas

Book Title: News Values
Authors: Paul Brighton & Dennis Foy
Sage Publications
Paperback, 205 pages, 18.99 Pounds
Sage Publications, ISBN 978-1-4129-4600-1
www.sagepublications.com


What are News Values? Is there any specific criteria for selecting news? Does celebrity news warrant more bytes than that of problems faced by the common man? These are questions that have troubled me for a long time. In fact ever since liberalization happened and news became a commodity to be sold and purchased just like any other. It’s a deplorable trend but with a large number of Media players in the market and a distinct dearth in creativity and social understanding it is something that was just waiting to happen…especially in India. In the purest sense everything that happens in the world is a new event and it’s eminently likely that someone , somewhere will have some level of interest in that occurrence. But what takes it from being different to being news? The approach to the delivery and packaging of news has altered with the passage of time, and the shape of the media in the 21st century is quite different from how it was 40 years ago.
The set of values applied by different media are also as varied as the media themselves. Therefore some form of a matrix system was needed to prioritise those events , to filter them into levels of applicability and relevance to the audience. Johan Galtung and Mari Homboe Ruge’s paper titled ‘Structuring and selecting news’ was the groundbreaking research paper that has become the core text for the purpose of evaluating ‘news values’. The current book under review is basically an expanded and more extensive in-depth version of that core text. Galtung and Ruge concentrated solely on Normay for their data analysis and this works against their validity today.
Monikered ‘News Values’, co-authored by Paul Brighton and Dennis Foy, this is a book that draws up a set of rules for journalists and editors to follow –by which to work, from which to plan and execute the content of a publication or a broadcast. Previous accounts of news values tended to be of two kinds-the first examined news stories from the perspective of the working journalist and tried to isolate the features of an event which make it likely to qualify as newsworthy. The second attempts a broader approach- incorporating areas such as ideology, cultural conditioning, technological determinism and others. The authors of ‘News Values’ are convinced that a third approach is needed in conjunction with these two existing schools of thought. They opine that that third approach is necessary because of changes within individual media and because of the shift in the nature of the relationships between providers and consumers of news.
In order to explore their thesis the authors have conducted detailed analysis of news output in print , broadcast and new media. Through the course of this book the authors analyse the various branches of the media and it’s key players with a view to establishing the values which apply for this great new age of media. The authors take note of the fact that in broadcast news issues of programme format contend with more traditional news values in determining which stories are selected for mainstream network television news bulletins. They examine how stories’ inclusion and prominence in television bulletins are shaped by stylistic as well as aesthetic factors. They investigate the role of story treatments in broadcast news- such factors as the overall shape of the programme package, the live two-way exchange between studio and on-location reporter, live voice-piece etc. which affect the editorial decision making process. They also examine how far the same issues govern story selection in radio, role of planning in news output, the role of the change in newspaper(evolution from fact to comment in print journalism) and what are the criteria adopted in the decision to include or exclude events which are not of immediate significance.
This book though very useful to journalists for the understanding it gives them about newsworthiness of events, is not going to be applicable in the heat of a newsroom(where the journalist is usually led by instinct). Instead it is a system which helps explain what makes news newsworthy for the benefit of students and analysts of all media forms. Journalism colleges and Media training Institutes should have it in their curriculum.

Johnson Thomas

The Internet and the Mass Media, Authors: Lucy Kung, Robert G Picard, Ruth Towse, Book Review by Johnson Thomas

Book Title: The Internet and The Mass Media

Authors: Lucy Kung, Robert G. Picard, Ruth Towse

Paperback edition, Pages :182

ISBN- 978-1-4129-4735-0
Sage publications
www.sagepublications.com

This is probably the most opportune time to discuss the impact of the Internet and mass media on our day-to-day lives. When technological changes take place , they are exciting, sometimes destructive and confusing and even have the power to alter the status quo. Young people adopt them faster than old people and richer countries and people have access to them much before poorer countries and people. There are many dimensions to these changes and they have to be considered from many points of view-as economic, social and political opportunities and threats. These changes impact on the whole of society both within a country and in the international context.

The 26/11 ambush on Mumbai orchestrated by terrorists allegedly from across the border, found incessant expression on the internet and mass media. Live telecasted shot-by-shot accounts by Indian news channels and individual bloggers have in fact created a storm of public opinion in favor of and against the indiscriminate use of mass media.

While the Indian newscasters upped their celeb and shrill quotient to grab maximum TRP’s, the foreign channels like BBC and CNN played it cool by calling in their experts, Christianne Amanpour and Co, when necessary, while the regular newscasters kept to their schedules with frequent updates on the terror attacks on Mumbai. The Indian counterparts were seen to be scrambling for one-upmanship, rattling off the number of shots fired, number of grenades thrown, number of terrorists, NSG, Marcos and police commandos in action while throwing in live interviews with the culprits, in an effort to pack the air waves with maximum bytes. And the fact was that none of it was entirely accurate, thus exposing their lack of expertise. It also compromised the whole operation as revealed by Naval Chief Admiral Mehta in a recent press conference when he called the media a ‘disabling instrument of the country.’
The strangely hypnotic and trancelike dance of death as relayed by the newscasters was like a c-grade bollywood product that went on and on, seemingly never ending in it’s narrative elongation and ridiculous in it’s numerous mini-climaxes. In fact when the inhuman bloodbath found it’s logical end, everyone from the security forces, the politicians to the newscasters were found wanting and were left red in the face! And , the viewers were in a state of shock; when it wore off the shock turned into anger. Of course, the erstwhile newscasters, not realizing their own susceptibility, continued to ply their idiot-box faithful with their seemingly holier-than-thou craft.

The internet, on the other hand played a much more mature role of news disseminator, providing a detailed view of what transpired without resorting to jingoism or melodrama. Blogs, file sharing websites and other websites like Twitter.com which provided short text updates were hotting up with messages at the press of a button. Bloggers relayed messages and pictures much faster than the news channels could. News appeared to be more accurate and precise on the net than on the news channels. Citizen journalists also joined in with first person accounts and on-the-spot frames. There were a few bloopers too, but they were few and less compromising than what was shown on television and this despite the fact that the internet is a wild untamed, uncontrolled and unregulated space. During the sixty hour siege of Mumbai there was a time when the news channels were blocked for a few hours but the internet carried on unhindered. The impact of this multi-media news-rush is there for all to see. People are enraged and becoming more demonstrative, Politicians are slipping out of their comfort zones, intelligence agencies are getting the short end of the public ire and media persons are forced to defend their ethics. Events like the one in Mumbai have definitely propelled new media to the forefront, it has not only gained recognition but also a faithful following.

But this was not the case five or even ten years ago. Take the case of music; five years ago when P2P and MP3 were setting shop, the industry were all jittery perceiving file-sharing as something likely to precipitate a crisis, reducing sales and cutting off revenue streams. But today the industry reckons that the internet has made business more secure and easier to expand. Sales have increased tremendously and revenues from licenses have added many zeros to the returns. Electronic books were similarly perceived as a hindrance to paper book sales but today not much has progressed on that front. There are many more examples to demonstrate the effect of the internet and the mass media but examples quickly date: what is attempted in this book is an overview not so much of the outcomes of the use of the internet but more of how social scientists set about analyzing the processes involved in the adoption of, adaptation to and acceptance of the internet in the context of media studies.

This book is the result of an initiative by the European Science foundation’s Committee on Science and Technology(COST) procedures that led to the COST A20 Project, that measured the ‘Impact of the Internet on the Mass Media.’ Spearheaded and Planned by Professor Colin Sparks, the moving force behind this initiative, a group of people from different countries, experts from different disciplines, met regularly to exchange intellectual viewpoints on a topic that was arguably difficult to analyze. The authors of this book are social scientists from all across Europe doing research in the field of media industries and specializing in a range of disciplines media and business economics, communications, cultural economics, cultural studies, media management, media technology, political science and sociology. They also share an interest in the impact of the internet on mass media. This book draws together what the authors have jointly concluded about the impact of the internet on the media industries. The book’s standpoint is multi-lens, interdisciplinary and cross national. The aim of this book was to present a contemporaneous account of researches arising out of objective academic investigation and this I say has been achieved without much difficulty!

Johnson Thomas